From: www.SilentMajority.co.UK/EUroRealist 
File: EUro CAN ONLY FAIL MonS 020609.rtf
Mail on Sunday
Financial Section 2002.06.09
A test of time that the Euro can only fail
By:    Dan Atkinson

Take a time machine trip back to the spring of 1988, the high noon of Nigel Lawson's balmy boom.  Swig Mexican lager from the bottle and sing along with the big hit-makers of the time, Prefab Sprout, Aztec Camera, Bananarama, Paolo Cecchini.  Paolo who?  Wasn't he that trendy fashion designer?

In a manner of speaking.  Cecchini was the economist asked by the European Commission to put a figure on the benefits that would flow from the planned creation of a single European market by the end of 1992.

Cecchini obliged and in May 1988 his report declared that, in the medium term, the tearing down of trade barriers among European Union countries would deliver truly staggering gains for the economies involved.

There would be a one-time boost to Gross Domestic Product of up to seven per cent.  And between 1.8 million and 5 million jobs would be created.  Commission vice-president Lord Cockfield (remember him?) beamed with pride.  "We are on the move", he declared, gloating over the "immense opportunities" presented by Project 1992/

Now, "medium term" is a slippery concept, but one might have thought that, ten years on from 1992 and 14 years on from Cecchini, we could finally judge the accuracy of those glowing forecasts.

So how did it go?  "By 1996, the boost to GDP was just 1.5 per cent and just one million jobs had been created.  Now it is 2002 and there is little to suggest that we have realised even half the potential gains of the single market."

Says who?  Well, that was Treasury Minister Ruth Kelly, commenting recently on the realisation (or not, in this case) of Cecchini's gold-plated predictions.  She was far too polite to say so, but the fact is that the Cecchini forecasts were about as reliable as all of those official figures of yesteryear "proving" that East Germany had the fifth biggest economy in Europe or that Castro's Cuba was a Caribbean paradise on earth. 

For all its tables and "methodology", the report was little more than propaganda, mixed with a heavy dose of bureaucratic wishful thinking.  That was then, of course, and we have "moved on".  But there are three critical lessons to be learned from the utter failure of the single market to deliver on its big-talking promises. 

First, Project 1992 was almost entirely uncontroversial:  a great chorus line of worthies from Lady Thatcher to Sir Edward Heath, Neil Kinnock to Lord Young stepped through the same thigh-slapping routine as they cheered to the rafters the greatest economic show on earth.  Only a handful of (highly courageous) oddballs declared either that the "benefits" had been hallucinated into existence by power-hungry Eurocrats or that no amount of additional GDP could compensate for the surrender of the British veto in Brussels as majority voting was brought in - ostensibly to "complete" the single market.

By contrast, British membership of the single currency is enormously controversial.  What is more, there is not and never has been any Cecchini-style report lauding the huge "gains" to be reaped from the euro.  True, Commission President Jacques Delors did present his own report on economic and monetary union 11 months after Cecchini.

But no numbers were ever put on the "payback" from European Monetary Union (EMU):  Delors simply accused those who opposed it of being "the sorcerer's apprentices" - Delors-speak for fascists, racists and anyone else unpleasant he could think of.  

Thus, in order to get the British public to swallow the gnat of the single market, a lavish coating of synthetic syrup was applied, in the form of Cecchini.  To get them to swallow the camel of abolishing the pound, there is not a spoonful of sugar in sight.  Second, as Kelly's remarks make clear, the Treasury is well aware that Project 1992 was sold on a false prospectus.  It is even more acutely aware that British membership of the euro is being sold on practically no prospectus at all, merely a vague collection of "threats" about Britain "being left out".

And it is the Treasury that has to assess the desirability or otherwise of that membership.  Knowing what it does, how can its verdict be anything other than a big thumbs down?

Thus, May 1988 was, relatively speaking, an age of innocence.  The wobbly bridge linking Project 1992 with the euro - the Exchange Rate Mechanism - had yet to throw a million Britons out of their jobs and out of their homes.

White Wednesday was still four years away.

It was still - just - excusable to believe that Project 1992, the ERM and EMU represented a shining path to the 21st century.There is no excuse now.  Indeed a "yes" from the Treasury would be the crowning disgrace for the department that gave us the Lawson boom, the ERM, rail privatisation and the farcical public/private partnership and has been wrong on just about every single issue since the First World War.

Assessing the euro is a Treasury "test" in more than one sense.
-----End of original message-----

Dan Atkinson’s ‘e’Mail address quoted with the article was:
Dan.Atkinson@MailOnSunday.co.UK

with thanks for transcription to Joan Northam-----

There is a CopyRight on this document, which is one of many 1,000s of items freely available on http://www.SilentMajority.co.UK [some 20Mbs.] & 10s of 1,000s of items on The SilentMajority CD [with over 80Mbs.] which contains the entire web site & hosts other web sites also, 1,000s of apposite quotations, Articles, Speeches, Commentaries, ArtWork, & The FULL text of The EU Treaties, Several Related Books, The British Constitution, The American Constitution & Numerous related Items.
SilentMajority nor any associate thereof does NOT vouch for the veracity of the documents hosted on its site or CD nor any foreign language documents thereon & advises you consult your own solicitor on legal details as we do not accept liability for, nor presume to give legal advice ourselves.
For a copy of the CD please mail payment of £20.00 for UK deliver or £25.00 for ALL other Countries payable to:
Greg Lance – Watkins,
Glance Back Books,
17 Upper Church Street,
CHEPSTOW,
NP16 5EX
Monmouthshire,
GREAT BRITAIN
For delivery of 2 x CDs
one for your own use
+ one for on selling or donation to an individual of influence (media, politician, activist etc.)

IF YOU wish to use the Material Above, which is freely provided
Please have the Courtesy to Print It out in its entirety from start to finish with NO alterations, as displayed.
To This Point
.